03/11/2026
RESPONSES TO FACEBOOK QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
HMM thanks everyone for your comments and questions. We have done our best to respond to the questions raised below. If you have further questions or comments, please feel free to contact us on:
•WhatsApp: 072 622 7769
•Email: [email protected].
We have reviewed all comments and grouped the questions that were similar and our responses are below:
1. Does South32 have the mining right for sugilite?
HMM’s mining right has been in effect since 2005, when it was converted to a new order mining right. The Minister of the Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources (DMPR) further confirmed the right in a letter in December 2024, which we have shared widely and can provide on request.
HMM’s mining right is publicly available under number NC 253 MR for Wessels Mine, where sugilite is found. It allows HMM to mine and dispose of the minerals, including sugilite, within its legally approved mining areas.
2. Why establish Tumalano Foundation instead of using an existing structure?
Feedback from the eight months community engagements indicated that many participants favoured the establishment of a new structure, with some stakeholders questioning the integrity and effectiveness of the current structures.
A non profit company (NPC) was proposed over a Trust because it has formal and stringent governance, accounting and reporting requirements that can support transparency and accountability.
3. What is the role of the Interim Board, and how long will it serve?
South32 has appointed employees as the Interim Directors of Tumalano Foundation. The appointments are temporary and support the establishment and registration of the NPC.
The Interim Directors are responsible for:
• Registering Tumalano Foundation as an NPC.
• Ensuring legal compliance, including drafting the Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) with legal support from a law firm.
• Setting up the required governance and administrative systems.
• Developing and implementing a fair and transparent framework for community membership.
• The Interim Directors will not manage or allocate the Foundation’s funds. The Permanent Board will make decisions on funding and projects.
The Interim Directors’ term ends once the first Community Members are admitted, the Permanent Board is appointed, and the Board has held its first formal meeting.
The Permanent Board may amend the MOI that established Tumalano Foundation if necessary.
4. Are Permanent Board members appointed permanently?
No. Directors of the Permanent Board will serve for a limited term of up to three years, as set out in the MOI.
The Permanent Board is the Board that will take over from the Interim Board.
5. How will the Directors of the Permanent Board be selected?
Tumalano Foundation will consist of 7 Directors and 20 Members.
The Permanent Board’s 7 Directors will each serve a term of up to three years and will be selected as follows:
• 3 Directors chosen by HMM, as the Founder.
• 4 Directors chosen by the Community through an open and transparent process.
An Advisory Committee, with representatives from across the JTG District, will support community participation in the process. The proposed representatives are:
• Representatives of Traditional Authority jurisdictions in Joe Morolong.
• Representatives of wards in Ga-Segonyana and Gamagara outside Traditional Authority jurisdictions.
• JTG District representatives, including local and district municipalities, Traditional Authorities, Civil Society Organisations and Communal Property Associations.
A separate Facebook post will share the detailed representation and nomination process.
The Advisory Committee will select up to 20 Members of Tumalano Foundation, who will then elect the 4 Community Directors. Selection criteria, including the required skills and competencies, will guide the process.
Tumalano Foundation Directors will not be paid for their role and services. Approved expenses, such as travel costs, may be reimbursed.
6. What projects will the Tumalano Foundation fund?
The Permanent Board will establish the funding process and choose which projects the Foundation supports.
The Board will publicly share its funding process and decisions in due course. Transparency and accountability will guide the Foundation’s work.
7. How were communities consulted?
HMM appointed an independent consulting firm to conduct community engagements across the JTG District from August 2025 to April 2026. These engagements reached more than 2,500 people and gathered valuable input on how a Community Benefit Mechanism could be established and governed. We used a sampling approach that is acceptable for social research. HMM had planned workshops at the end of the study to give feedback and elect community representatives to take the work forward. However, the workshops were disrupted and posed a security risk to HMM and its employees, so other engagement methods were used instead, including virtual meetings, social media posts, radio and print media.
We acknowledge that we could not engage with everyone, and doing so would not be practical. Information has been shared extensively through platforms including weekly Microsoft Teams meetings, Facebook, WhatsApp broadcasts and a radio series.
HMM remains committed to engaging with stakeholders and will share the findings of the engagements on request.
Community members and interested stakeholders can provide further input through:
• WhatsApp: 072 622 7769
• Email: [email protected]
8. How will HMM sell sugilite?
HMM will use its existing sales process, which is managed by South32 Marketing Department.